Discover the Best Value Used Year Model of Jeep Wrangler to Buy

21 min read

Lesly Ernser, Cars Senior Writer

Published:

Buckle up, adventure enthusiasts, and savvy spenders! If you’re on the trail to finding a rugged ride without breaking the bank, you’ve just struck gold. Today we’re diving under the hood to reveal the ultimate find in the world of hearty vehicles: Discover the Best Value Used Year Model of Jeep Wrangler to Buy. Join us as we navigate through the terrain of resale value, performance checks, and hidden gems that will ensure you clinch the deal on a Wrangler that won’t just carry you through the wilds but will also be a wallet-friendly champion of the road. Let’s kick off this journey and find you the perfect mix of horsepower and savings!

We break down how much you save buying recent year models vs. new

We break down how much you save buying recent year models vs. new

When looking for the best value used Jeep Wrangler to buy, several factors come into consideration. Jeep Wranglers are known for their durability and longevity which can make them great used vehicle purchases. However, as with buying any used car, the savings you achieve compared to buying new will vary depending on the year model and its depreciation, as well as its condition, mileage, and location.

Here’s a breakdown of how you could potentially save money buying recent year models versus brand new:

  1. Depreciation:

    • A new car depreciates the most in its first year, typically around 20-30%. Jeep Wranglers, however, tend to hold their value better than many other vehicles. Even so, you can expect a Wrangler to lose some of its value once it’s driven off the lot.
    • By the third year, a vehicle will often depreciate by about 40-50% of its original value. A used Wrangler three years old could offer significant savings over a new model and will still likely be in good condition.
  2. Mileage:

    • A gently used Wrangler with low mileage can be an excellent purchase. The key is finding one that hasn’t been driven too hard, especially off-road, as this can affect the future maintenance and lifespan of the vehicle.
  3. Maintenance and Warranty:

    • Newer used Wranglers may still be covered under the manufacturer’s warranty, offering you some peace of mind. However, this also means you won’t save as much as with an older model that’s out of warranty.
  4. Model Year Updates:

    • Jeep Wranglers don’t see significant redesigns very often, but when they do, the models just prior to the redesign could see a sharper drop in resale value as buyers desire the updated features. This could be an opportunity to buy a relatively new Wrangler for less.
  5. Insurance and Registration Fees:

    • Typically, these costs are lower for used cars since they are based on the value of the car. A recent model year used Wrangler should cost less to insure and register than a new one.

For those interested in the best value, look into purchasing a Jeep Wrangler that is around three to four years old. This range often strikes a balance between benefiting from initial depreciation and still acquiring a relatively new vehicle that isn’t likely to need expensive repairs any time soon.

For example, if the latest model year is 2023, a 2019 or 2020 Jeep Wrangler would provide several years of modern amenities and style with a much lower price tag than the brand new version. Additionally, favor models that have lower mileage and a clean history which can indicate a well-maintained vehicle.

Always have any used vehicle inspected by a trusted mechanic before purchase and consider certified pre-owned options that can offer additional warranties and assurances at a higher but potentially worthwhile cost.

What Did Used Jeep Wranglers Cost When They Were New?

What Did Used Jeep Wranglers Cost When They Were New?

When looking for the best value used Jeep Wrangler, understanding what these vehicles cost when they were new can help you gauge the depreciation and find a model that offers the most for your money. The cost of a new Jeep Wrangler has increased over the years, reflecting changes in features, inflation, and market demand.

Here’s a generalized overview of how Jeep Wrangler pricing has evolved over the past few decades:

  • 1990s models (YJ and early TJ): Original MSRPs for the Wrangler in the early '90s started around $10,000 to $15,000. Inflation-adjusted, these figures might be comparable to roughly $20,000 to $25,000 today, but it’s worth noting that these models were much less sophisticated in terms of technology and features compared to current models.

  • 2000s models (TJ and early JK): By the 2000s, a base Wrangler TJ could start around $18,000, and a decade later, the base price for a Wrangler JK was close to $22,000. Adjusting for inflation, these prices might correspond to the upper $20,000s to lower $30,000s in today’s dollars.

  • 2010s models (JK and early JL): As we move into the 2010s, the Wrangler JK continued to rise in price, with later models and upper trims reaching into the mid-$30,000s when they were new. The introduction of the Wrangler JL in 2018 saw base prices starting around $28,000, with well-equipped models stretching into the $40,000 range.

  • 2020s models (JL and upcoming new generations): The current generation Wrangler JL has seen prices that begin in the low $30,000s for base models, with some special editions and fully-loaded Rubicon models surpassing $50,000.

When searching for the best value, consider looking for Wranglers that are 5-10 years old. These vehicles have typically undergone the majority of their depreciation but often still offer modern features and reliability. The JK models from the later 2000s to early 2010s can be a sweet spot as they offer a good balance between modern amenities and more reasonable prices.

Inspect the vehicle’s history, condition, mileage, and specific model year changes that could influence the desirability. Specialty models like the Rubicon have higher starting prices but also tend to maintain their value better due to off-road enthusiasts seeking their advanced capabilities.

Remember, the best value doesn’t necessarily mean the cheapest price. It’s about finding a Wrangler that offers the most in terms of condition, features, and performance relative to its price and potential lifespan. Doing thorough research and sometimes opting for a slightly older model or one with fewer options can sometimes provide the most bang for your buck.

2015 Jeep Wrangler: Used vs. New Price & Feature Comparison

2015 Jeep Wrangler: Used vs. New Price & Feature Comparison

When considering purchasing a used Jeep Wrangler, the 2015 model year is often recognized as a great value option. To determine if this specific year is the best value for you, we should compare it to a new Jeep Wrangler in terms of price and features.

Price:

A used 2015 Jeep Wrangler is significantly less expensive than a new model. Depreciation plays a significant role in the price difference; the initial depreciation hit has already been absorbed by the first owner. On average, a new car loses around 20-30% of its value within the first year and about 50% or more over three years. By the time a vehicle is five to eight years old, it has usually gone through the steepest part of its depreciation curve.

The exact price of a used 2015 Jeep Wrangler can vary based on mileage, condition, location, and specific trim. However, you can expect to pay anywhere from half to two-thirds of the vehicle’s original MSRP depending on these factors. In contrast, a new Jeep Wrangler’s price can be significantly higher, especially with new features, technology, and any additional dealer fees.

Features:

The 2015 Jeep Wrangler retains the ruggedness and off-road capabilities that the model is known for. It may lack some of the latest technology and safety features found in the newest models but still holds strong with the essentials that define a Wrangler, including its robust 4x4 systems, the 3.6L V6 engine offering a good balance of power and efficiency, and the classic Jeep design.

The newer models may have advanced features such as improved infotainment systems, driver-assistance technologies, and more refined interiors. However, for those who are more interested in the traditional Jeep experience rather than the latest gadgets, the 2015 Wrangler will likely suffice.

Reliability and Maintenance:

Another factor to consider is reliability and maintenance. The 2015 Jeep Wrangler has had time for any common issues to surface and be addressed. When buying a used vehicle, it’s essential to review its maintenance history and possibly get a pre-purchase inspection to ensure it’s in good condition.

New vehicles come with warranties that can provide peace of mind, but they also come with a higher price tag. A well-maintained 2015 Wrangler can provide reliability at a lower upfront cost, but it’s essential to set aside a budget for potential repairs since it will be out of factory warranty.

Conclusion:

The 2015 Jeep Wrangler offers a good balance between price and features for those who want the classic Jeep driving experience without the higher cost of a new vehicle. While you will miss out on the latest technology and safety enhancements, the savings on the purchase price could make it the best value used year model of Jeep Wrangler to buy. Always ensure that you have a complete inspection and service history check before making a purchase to avoid costly surprises down the road.

2016 Jeep Wrangler: Used vs. New

2016 Jeep Wrangler: Used vs. New

When exploring the best value used year model of Jeep Wrangler, especially in comparison to buying a new one, the 2016 Jeep Wrangler stands out as a particularly appealing option for several reasons:

  1. Depreciation Benefits: The value of a new car depreciates quite rapidly within the first few years. By opting for a 2016 model, you can take advantage of the significant depreciation that has already occurred, letting you get more bang for your buck.

  2. Proven Reliability: As it’s been on the road for several years, the reliability of the 2016 Jeep Wrangler is better understood. You can research common issues, long-term durability, and owner reviews to gather a realistic expectation of what the vehicle will require in terms of maintenance.

  3. Aftermarket Support: The 2016 model has a mature aftermarket support, offering a plethora of customization options and parts. This is a huge plus for Wrangler enthusiasts who look to personalize their rides.

  4. Insurance Costs: Older vehicles typically cost less to insure. The 2016 Wrangler will likely come with lower insurance premiums compared to a new model, thereby saving you money annually.

  5. Time-Tested Model: The 2016 Wrangler hails from a period before any major redesigns, retaining the traditional Jeep characteristics and design elements that many purists prefer.

Before purchasing a used 2016 Jeep Wrangler, be sure to:

  • Get a vehicle history report.
  • Have a pre-purchase inspection done by a professional to check for any hidden problems.
  • Verify the vehicle’s service records to ensure it has been properly maintained.
  • Consider the mileage, as lower mileage often correlates with a shorter lifespan of potential problems, although well-maintained high-mileage vehicles can also be a good buy.

The value prospect of a 2016 Jeep Wrangler is grounded in practical considerations such as cost savings, proven performance, and a strong community and aftermarket presence. Ultimately, when compared to buying new, a used 2016 Wrangler offers a financially savvy way into the adventurous lifestyle coveted by Jeep enthusiasts.

2017 Jeep Wrangler: Used vs. New

2017 Jeep Wrangler: Used vs. New

When deciding between a new Jeep Wrangler and a used one, considering the 2017 Jeep Wrangler as a potential best-value purchasing option is a smart move. The 2017 model can offer the classic Wrangler experience with modern comforts at a more affordable price than its newer counterparts. To determine if it’s the best value used year model for you, take the following factors into account:

  1. Depreciation: Vehicles depreciate the most within the first few years of purchase. A 2017 Jeep Wrangler has already gone through a significant portion of its depreciation, meaning you’ll get a better price without the vehicle being too outdated.

  2. Reliability: The 2017 Jeep Wrangler is known for its durability and reliability, attributes that are highly sought-after in used vehicles. Make sure to verify the vehicle’s maintenance history to ensure it hasn’t been subjected to extreme off-roading or neglect.

  3. Features: Even though the 2017 model won’t include the latest technology and features found in the newest models, it still offers enough amenities to keep the driving experience enjoyable. Verify which features are essential for you and compare them with what the 2017 Wrangler provides.

  4. Insurance Costs: Older vehicles typically cost less to insure. By opting for a 2017 model, you might reduce your yearly insurance expenses.

  5. Resale Value: Jeep Wranglers tend to hold their value exceptionally well. If you decide to sell the 2017 model in the future, you’re likely to recoup a significant portion of your investment, especially if the vehicle is well-maintained.

  6. Modification and Accessories Market: The 2017 Jeep Wrangler has a vast array of aftermarket parts and accessories available, making it easy to customize your Jeep to your liking, which may not be as extensive for newer models.

  7. Reviews and Common Issues: Research reviews and consumer feedback for the 2017 Wrangler to learn about any common issues or recalls. Addressing these problems before purchasing can save you from future headaches.

When comparing used versus new, always consider your personal needs, including your budget, preference for modern tech, performance requirements, and the intended use of the vehicle (daily driving, off-roading, etc.). Always have a used vehicle inspected by a professional mechanic before purchasing to ensure you’re getting a Wrangler in good condition. The best-value used year model of the Jeep Wrangler is subjective and hinges on the factors most important to you as an owner.

2018 Jeep Wrangler Used vs. New: Price and Feature Comparison

2018 Jeep Wrangler Used vs. New: Price and Feature Comparison

When considering the purchase of a Jeep Wrangler, the 2018 model year represents a particularly interesting opportunity. The 2018 year marks the transition between the older JK series and the introduction of the newer JL series. Here is a comparison of used vs. new vehicle considerations, focusing on price and features:

  1. Depreciation and Price:
  • Used 2018 Jeep Wrangler JK models will have experienced the initial depreciation hit, making them more affordable compared to new models. Depreciation is steepest in the first year and levels off after 3-4 years.
  • A used 2018 JL, being the first model year of the redesign, may still command a higher price due to its novelty and updates over the JK, but it will also have depreciated somewhat since release.
  1. Features and Updates:
  • The 2018 JL introduced several improvements over the JK including a more modern interior, improved aerodynamics, and lighter materials for better fuel efficiency.
  • Engine options were updated in the JL, with a 2.0-liter turbocharged four-cylinder being offered alongside the traditional 3.6-liter V6.
  • The JL also brought enhancements such as a backup camera, keyless entry, and an optional power-operated top.
  1. Reliability and Reviews:
  • The JK model had many years to refine and iron out any issues, potentially making the later JK years more reliable.
  • As the 2018 JL was the first of its series, it could potentially have first-year teething problems which are common in new models. Checking reliability reports and owner reviews is important when shopping for a vehicle.
  1. Future Resale Value:
  • Jeeps, in general, tend to hold their value well, and the Wrangler is particularly known for its strong resale.
  • A more recent model, with updated features, can be expected to have a higher resale value, making the 2018 JL a potentially better long-term investment compared to a JK of the same year.

Conclusion:

When seeking the best value used year model of Jeep Wrangler, the 2018 JK can be a great buy if you’re looking for tried-and-tested reliability at a more affordable price. However, if you’re willing to spend a bit more for the latest features and design updates, a used 2018 JL could be worth the extra investment. Before making a decision, it’s crucial to inspect the specific used vehicle’s history, condition, mileage, and ownership costs, and consider how the updates in the newer JL align with your priorities for a Jeep Wrangler.

2019 Jeep Wrangler Used vs. New: Price and Feature Comparison

2019 Jeep Wrangler Used vs. New: Price and Feature Comparison

When looking for the best value used year model of Jeep Wrangler to buy, considering a 2019 Jeep Wrangler can be a beneficial choice. Let’s delve into a price and feature comparison between a used 2019 model and a new one to understand why the 2019 model might offer the best value.

Price Comparison: Used cars depreciate the most during the first few years after manufacture. By the time a vehicle is about three years old, it can lose close to 40-50% of its original value. The 2019 Jeep Wrangler is no exception to this rule. When you opt for a used 2019 Wrangler, you should expect to see a significant decrease in price compared to its new counterpart. The exact price difference will vary depending on factors like condition, mileage, and location, but used buyers will invariably benefit financially.

Feature Comparison: The Jeep Wrangler’s design hasn’t dramatically changed in recent years. Therefore, a 2019 model will have many of the same core features as the newer models. This includes:

  1. Body Style: The two main body styles, the two-door and the four-door (Unlimited), should be the same between 2019 and the newer models.

  2. Engine Options: In 2019, Jeep offered a 3.6L V6 engine as well as a 2.0L turbocharged inline-4 engine. These options provide a balance between performance and fuel efficiency that remains relatively comparable to newer models.

  3. Off-Road Capability: One of the Wrangler’s main selling points is its off-road capability, and the 2019 model features solid axles, a body-on-frame design, and available four-wheel drive, much like the newer versions.

  4. Technology & Interior: While newer models might have slight upgrades in technology and materials, the 2019 model comes with a user-friendly infotainment system, optional touchscreens of various sizes, and Apple CarPlay/Android Auto availability.

Advantages of Buying Used:

  1. Lower Initial Cost: You save money on the initial purchase when you buy used.

  2. Slower Depreciation: With the major hit on depreciation already taken, the used model doesn’t lose value as quickly.

  3. Insurance Costs: Generally, insuring a used vehicle tends to be less expensive.

  4. Certified Pre-Owned Options: Certified Pre-Owned (CPO) Wranglers might still have part of their original warranty, which can provide additional peace of mind with some benefits comparable to a new-car warranty.

Potential Downsides of Buying Used:

  1. Mileage and Wear: The used vehicle will have mileage and some wear and tear.

  2. Limited Selection: You might have to compromise on color or certain features based on what’s available in the used market.

  3. Higher Financing Rates: Generally, used car loans may come with higher interest rates compared to new cars.

When deciding between a used 2019 Jeep Wrangler and a new model, it’s important to weigh the financial benefits against your preferences for technology and the latest design. If the updates to the new models are not deal-breakers for you, then the 2019 Jeep Wrangler equipped with robust features and a significantly lower price tag can offer the best value for your investment. Always remember to inspect any used vehicle thoroughly or consider getting a pre-purchase inspection by a professional to ensure the vehicle is in good condition before making a purchase.

Jeep Wrangler Problems To Look For

Jeep Wrangler Problems To Look For

When looking for the best value used year model of a Jeep Wrangler, it’s essential to consider both the vehicle’s reputation and any common problems associated with different model years. Jeep Wranglers are known for their off-road capability and ruggedness, but like any vehicle, certain years have been known to have more issues than others.

2007-2011 Jeep Wrangler JK: The earlier years of the JK generation, specifically 2007-2011, had some notable problems such as issues with the Totally Integrated Power Module (TIPM) which could affect the vehicle’s electrical systems. There were also complaints about the 3.8L V6 engine being underpowered and less reliable compared to the later engines.

2012-2017 Jeep Wrangler JK: In 2012, the Wrangler received a significant upgrade with the introduction of the 3.6L Pentastar V6 engine, which offered improved power and efficiency. While this engine is generally more reliable than its predecessor, there are still issues to watch out for, especially concerning the cylinder head in earlier Pentastar models. Additionally, watch for the early signs of wear in the automatic transmission and leaks from the oil cooler.

2018-present Jeep Wrangler JL: The Wrangler JL is the newest generation and includes a host of improvements over the JK. While the longevity data isn’t as comprehensive due to its recent release, initial quality reports are favorable. Some minor recalls and problems have been reported, but overall, the JLs are proving to be a good choice.

When seeking the best used Jeep Wrangler for value, you might want to target the later years of the JK generation (2012-2017). These models have a better engine and have been out long enough that many of the kinks have been worked out, but they haven’t depreciated as much as the newest JL models. A well-maintained 2015 or 2016 Jeep Wrangler could strike a good balance between age, reliability, and price.

When surveying potential purchases, there are specific problems to be vigilant about:

  1. Engine Issues: On the 3.8L engines, watch for ticking noises that could indicate worn lifters or a failing camshaft. On 3.6L engines, be wary of a whining noise from a faulty water pump or issues with the cylinder heads.

  2. Transmission Problems: Check the automatic transmission for smooth shifts. If it’s manual, ensure the clutch engages and disengages properly without grinding.

  3. Leaks: Inspect for oil leaks, especially around the oil cooler and rear main seal. The valve cover gasket is also a common leak point.

  4. Suspension and Steering: The Wrangler’s suspension and steering components can wear out, particularly if the vehicle has been used extensively off-road. Watch for loose steering feel, odd noises over bumps, and check the condition of the shocks, bushings, and suspension joints.

  5. Corrosion: While Wranglers are built to take on tough conditions, always check the underbody for excessive rust, especially if the vehicle has been used in areas with heavy snow and road salt.

  6. Electrical Systems: Make sure all the electrical components are in good working order. Pay attention to the power windows, locks, radio, and the functionality of the instrument cluster.

To ensure you’re getting the best deal, always seek out a pre-purchase inspection from a trusted mechanic with experience in Jeeps. This can help uncover problems that might not be immediately apparent. Additionally, ask for maintenance records to ensure the vehicle has been cared for properly.

Which Year Model Of Jeep Wrangler Is Best To Buy Used Vs. New?

Which Year Model Of Jeep Wrangler Is Best To Buy Used Vs. New?

When shopping for a used Jeep Wrangler, finding the best value often involves balancing price, reliability, and features. The Jeep Wrangler is known for its strong resale value and durability, which means even older models can still command a premium. However, some year models stand out for offering a good blend of value and performance.

One of the most recommended used Jeep Wrangler models is the 2013-2018 versions, specifically from the JK generation. This generation offered significant improvements over previous models, such as a more refined interior, better ride quality, and the introduction of the more powerful and efficient 3.6-liter Pentastar V6 engine in 2012. Models from 2013 onward have this engine and have had a year to work out any potential early production issues.

The 2015 Jeep Wrangler also stands out as a great option, as this model year added a Torx tool kit for removing the doors and roof, as well as an eight-speaker audio system and an optional nine-speaker Alpine system. It’s a sweet spot for buyers looking for modern amenities without paying near-new prices.

If you are open to the older generation, the 2007-2011 Jeep Wrangler models from the beginning of the JK series offer the classic Jeep experience. However, be aware that these come with the 3.8-liter V6 engine, which is less powerful and less fuel-efficient than the 3.6-liter Pentastar that succeeded it. These older models will be less expensive but may require more maintenance.

If you’re considering the newer JL model, used prices may still be quite high, as this generation started in 2018. The JL brought even more refinements and technology to the Wrangler, including advanced safety features, improved interiors, and better on-road performance while retaining its off-road prowess. Buying a used JL could still be a great value if you value the latest features.

When deciding between buying used versus new, consider the following:

  • Depreciation: A new car loses value as soon as it’s driven off the lot. A well-maintained, slightly used Wrangler can offer the same features at a lower cost.
  • Insurance Costs: Typically, insurance rates are lower for used vehicles.
  • Remaining Warranty: Depending on the used Wrangler’s age and mileage, it may still have some of its original manufacturer’s warranty left.

Always get a used vehicle inspected by a professional mechanic and check its history report before buying. Personal preference, budget, and the importance you place on modern features should all play a role in your decision on which year model of Jeep Wrangler is best for you to buy used vs. new.

Lesly Ernser, Cars Senior Writer
Lesly Ernser

Lesly Ernser is a Cars Senior Writer at a reputable automobile publication. With a passion for cars and a love